Sentence Mining

Also known as mining, i+1 sentences, 1T sentences, targeted sentence cards

Pull sentences you almost understand out of things you're already watching or reading, and turn each into one flashcard.

Sentence mining is a card-making discipline rather than a whole method. Instead of studying a pre-made list of words, you take your flashcards out of the material you personally consume: a line from an episode, a sentence from a novel, a phrase from a podcast. The governing rule is that a mined sentence should contain exactly one thing you don't know — the community calls this an i+1 or 1T ('one target') sentence. Everything else in it should already be familiar, so the sentence itself supplies the context that makes the new item memorable.

The argument for it is that words are not learned in isolation. A card that says 'kuyashii = frustrated' teaches you a gloss; a card carrying the line a character actually said, in a scene you remember, teaches you the register, the collocation and the grammar it sits in at the same time. It also guarantees relevance: everything on your cards is by construction something you met while doing something you wanted to do.

Mechanically, modern mining is fast because of tooling. A pop-up dictionary over a subtitle track, or a reader with one-click export, will build a card containing the sentence, the target word's definition, the audio clip and often a screenshot, in a couple of seconds. Card formats vary: some people put the whole sentence on the front and test comprehension, others cloze-delete the target word, and a well-known minimal-pairs variant tests only the one item with the sentence as a hint.

A realistic week is: watch an episode with subtitles on, save six to ten lines that were nearly clear, spend ten minutes tidying the cards, and review the accumulated deck daily. Practitioners generally cap new cards hard — ten or twenty a day — because the review load compounds and mining is very easy to overdo.

It is worth being clear about what sentence mining is and isn't. It is a way of feeding a spaced-repetition system with better material. It is not a source of input, and it does not replace the hours of watching and reading that generate the sentences in the first place. Mining without immersion produces a beautiful deck and very little comprehension.

How it works

  1. Consume native or near-native material you actually enjoy — that is the ore.
  2. Save only sentences where a single element is unknown; skip anything with two or more.
  3. Build the card with the full sentence, the target item's meaning, and the audio if you can get it.
  4. Keep one target per card, and delete cards you no longer care about rather than fighting them.
  5. Cap new cards per day (ten to twenty is common) so reviews stay under half an hour.
  6. Review daily in an SRS and re-encounter the words in the wild — the card is a reminder, not the learning.

Origin Khatzumoto and the AJATT community, late 2000s — Popularised on the All Japanese All The Time blog as the way to feed Anki, then systematised by the Japanese-learning community and built into mining tools.

Good for

  • Intermediate learners drowning in near-known vocabulary
  • Retaining words in the grammar and register they actually appear in
  • Anyone using subtitle tools or pop-up dictionaries, where mining is nearly free

Trade-offs

  • The i+1 rule is much harder to satisfy than it sounds. Below a large passive vocabulary almost every native sentence has two or three unknowns, which makes mining a poor fit for beginners — a frequency deck is faster at that stage.
  • It scales badly if you don't cap it. Every episode offers dozens of candidate cards, and unbounded mining produces a review queue that eventually eats the immersion time that fed it.
  • Card-making is a satisfying, measurable activity that feels like studying. It is easy to spend more of your week curating a deck than listening to the language.
  • Recognising a sentence on a card does not mean you can produce the word, and mined decks skew heavily toward passive recognition unless you deliberately add production cards.
  • Direct research on sentence mining as such is thin; the strong evidence underneath it is for spaced repetition and for context in vocabulary learning, not for this particular workflow.

Who advocates this

  • Khatzumoto Creator

    Popularised mining sentences into an SRS on the All Japanese All The Time blog.

  • Systematised mining card formats and criteria in MIA and later in Refold's guides.

  • Migaku Company

    Builds browser tooling whose core function is mining sentences from Netflix and YouTube into flashcards.

  • Tatsumoto Creator

    Pseudonymous author of the current AJATT site, which publishes a detailed sentence-mining guide and card templates.

Learners who used this

Field notes whose stack included this approach. It is an account of what one person did, not evidence that it works — and note how few run a single method on its own.

All field notes →

Resources that use this

Anki

Multi-language

The gold-standard spaced-repetition flashcard app with community decks for every language.

About this tool →
AppsTools Free BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced
Vocabulary
Details

Free on desktop, Android and web; the iOS app is a one-off paid purchase that funds the project. The interface is dated and the options are overwhelming at first, but nothing beats it for retaining vocabulary over years. Most effective when you stop grinding premade decks and start mining sentences from things you actually read or watch.

Migaku

Multi-language

Turns Netflix, YouTube and web pages into Anki-style sentence cards.

About this tool →
ToolsApps Paid IntermediateAdvanced
ImmersionVocabularyReadingListening
Details

The heavyweight immersion toolkit: one-click sentence mining with audio, screenshot and definitions, plus its own SRS and known-word tracking, for 11 languages including Japanese, Korean, Mandarin and the major European ones. A 10-day free trial then a subscription (roughly $10/month). Overkill unless you are committed to a sentence-mining routine — if that describes you it saves hours a week, otherwise Language Reactor's free tier is enough.

Language Reactor

Multi-language

Dual subtitles and click-to-look-up on Netflix and YouTube.

About this tool →
Tools Freemium IntermediateAdvanced
ListeningReadingVocabularyImmersion
Details

A Chrome extension that shows target-language and native subtitles simultaneously, lets you click any word for a definition, replay a line, and save phrases for review. The free tier already covers dual subs, dictionary lookups and the CEFR-graded video catalogue; Pro (about $6/month) adds machine translation, speech recognition and better AI lookups. It transforms passive Netflix time into study time, but you need enough of a base — roughly B1 — for subtitle mining to beat just watching.

Tells you the difficulty and exact vocabulary of specific anime, games and novels.

About this tool →
WebsitesTools Free IntermediateAdvanced A2–C1
VocabularyReadingImmersion
Details

Its killer feature is per-media word lists: look up a specific show or novel, see how many words it uses and what percentage you already know, then pre-study that deck before you start. The built-in SRS is fast and keyboard-driven. It is free but rough around the edges — sparse documentation, an opinionated review algorithm, and a small one-person-project feel — and it assumes you have already got past the beginner stage.

Clozemaster

Multi-language

Fill-in-the-blank sentence drills for vocabulary after you know the basics.

About this tool →
AppsTools Freemium IntermediateAdvanced A2–C1
VocabularyReadingGrammar
Details

Built on Tatoeba sentences, it drills words in context by frequency band across 50+ languages and 170+ language pairings, with a genuinely generous free tier. It explicitly starts where beginner apps end, so it is the natural 'what now?' answer for someone who finished a Duolingo tree. Sentences are crowd-sourced and occasionally awkward or oddly specific, and it teaches nothing about grammar explicitly.

Memrise

Multi-language

Vocabulary drills backed by clips of native speakers saying the phrase.

About this tool →
Apps Freemium BeginnerIntermediate A1–B1
VocabularyListeningSpeaking
Details

The 'learn with locals' video clips are the distinguishing feature — you hear real people at real speed rather than TTS. Be aware that Memrise moved user-created community courses off the main app in 2024 onto a separate site, which gutted what many long-time users valued most, and the app has leaned hard into AI chat features since. Fine as a phrase-and-vocabulary app for major languages; if you came for the community decks, use Anki instead.

Readlang

Multi-language

Click any word while reading the web to translate it and make a flashcard.

About this tool →
ToolsWebsites Freemium IntermediateAdvanced
ReadingVocabulary
Details

A browser extension plus web reader covering 100+ languages: click a word or drag across a phrase, get an inline translation, and it becomes a flashcard automatically. The free tier gives unlimited single-word translations but caps phrases and AI explanations at 10 a day; Premium is $6/month. Simpler and cheaper than LingQ or Migaku if all you want is frictionless reading of articles and ebooks.

Four hundred short Kurmanji lessons for English speakers.

About this tool →
YouTube Free BeginnerIntermediate
VocabularySpeakingPronunciation
Details

Themed vocabulary and everyday phrases in Kurmanji, the northern variety written in the Latin alphabet and spoken in Turkey and Syria. The largest English-medium Kurdish course there is, and it is explicit about which variety it teaches — which matters more in Kurdish than almost any other language on this site.

Nearly a thousand short Albanian lessons — the biggest free catalogue there is.

About this tool →
YouTube Free BeginnerIntermediate
VocabularySpeakingListening
Details

Phrases, question-and-answer sets, false friends and everyday vocabulary in very short videos. Albanian is an isolate within Indo-European — nothing you know transfers — so the sheer volume of repetition here is worth more than a tidier but smaller course.

A word of Estonian a day, six hundred videos deep.

About this tool →
YouTube Free Beginner
VocabularyPronunciation
Details

Short daily vocabulary videos from a teacher in Estonia, each on a single word with pronunciation and use. Not a course, and the format is exactly right for the drip-feed a hard language needs between study sessions — Estonian vocabulary shares almost nothing with English or Russian, so it has to be built one word at a time.

The best Tagalog dictionary, plus a reader, video library and SRS decks in one place.

About this tool →
DictionariesWebsitesToolsCommunities Freemium BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced A1–C1
VocabularyReadingListeningGrammar
Details

This is the hub of the Tagalog learning world: a dictionary of roughly 85,000 words with 66,000 native audio clips and 20,000 example sentences showing syllable stress and word-by-word breakdowns, alongside a text reader with click lookups, a daily-updated library of YouTube videos with transcripts, spaced-repetition decks including the well-known 2k frequency deck, and an active learner forum. If you use one Tagalog site, use this one. Much is free with an account, but the deepest dictionary and reader features sit behind a subscription, and the interface is dense rather than elegant.

Mnemonic-driven SRS that takes you through 2,000 kanji and 6,000 words in order.

About this tool →
AppsTools Paid BeginnerIntermediate A1–B2
ReadingVocabulary
Details

Radicals build into kanji which build into vocabulary, all on a spaced-repetition schedule you cannot rush — that enforced pacing is exactly why it works for people who bounce off self-managed Anki decks. Levels 1–3 are free; after that it is $9/month, $89/year or $299 lifetime (lifetime goes on sale most Decembers). Downsides: you cannot skip kanji you already know, the pace is fixed at roughly 1.5 years to finish, and it teaches readings rather than how to use the words in sentences.

Three hundred and sixty lessons pairing Pashto with Arabic.

About this tool →
YouTube Free BeginnerIntermediate
VocabularyReading
Details

Aimed at Pashto speakers learning Arabic and at Arabic speakers learning Pashto, so the direction varies video to video — check before you settle in. Included because the sheer volume of paired Pashto material is otherwise hard to find.

SRS for grammar points, N5 to N1, with links out to the best explanation of each.

About this tool →
WebsitesAppsTools Freemium BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced A1–C1
GrammarReading
Details

Fills the gap Anki and WaniKani leave: it drills grammar in cloze sentences and, for every point, links to the relevant page in Tae Kim, Genki, Imabi and others so you can read a real explanation before reviewing. There is a permanent free tier plus a 30-day full trial; Premium is $5/month or $150 lifetime, which is cheap for what it covers. It assumes you already have kana and some vocabulary, and it is a review tool rather than a first-time teacher.

Themed Burmese vocabulary sets — family dinner, business, politeness.

About this tool →
YouTube Free BeginnerIntermediate
VocabularyListeningSpeaking
Details

A hundred videos of thirty-words-at-a-time vocabulary grouped by situation, including a set on speaking respectfully. Burmese politeness levels are grammatical rather than optional, so a channel that treats them as a topic in their own right is doing something most beginner material skips.

The most complete Android kanji app: custom sets, writing practice, offline.

About this tool →
AppsTools Freemium BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced
ReadingWritingVocabulary
Details

Lets you build study sets by JLPT level, grade, frequency or your own list, with flashcards, multiple-choice quizzes, writing challenges and a built-in dictionary — all offline. The free version covers the first few JLPT levels; a single in-app purchase (around $12) unlocks everything permanently, with no subscription. Android only, and the sheer number of options takes a while to navigate.

A hundred short lessons on how to say everyday things in Nepali.

About this tool →
YouTube Free Beginner
VocabularySpeaking
Details

Bite-sized vocabulary and phrase videos aimed at English speakers. Nepali is written in Devanagari and shares a great deal with Hindi, so anyone with Hindi will move fast here — and should be careful, because the verb system and the honorific levels differ more than the vocabulary suggests.

One of the very few polished apps that actually covers Bengali.

About this tool →
Apps Freemium BeginnerIntermediate A1–A2
VocabularyListeningReadingWriting
Details

Ling is a gamified course app whose selling point is breadth — it covers languages the big apps skip, and Bengali is one of them, script included. Expect vocabulary, short dialogues and writing practice rather than deep grammar. The free tier is thin and the subscription is the real product; worth it mainly because the alternatives for structured beginner Bengali are so few.

Daily-practice app that covers Urdu script as well as phrases.

About this tool →
Apps Freemium BeginnerIntermediate A1–A2
VocabularyListeningReadingWriting
Details

Gamified lessons with native audio, and unusually for an app of this kind it does not skip the writing system. Useful as the daily-habit layer under a real course rather than as the course itself: it will build recognition vocabulary and will not explain Urdu's postpositions or its ergative past tense to you.

Handwriting SRS that grades every stroke as you write characters from memory.

About this tool →
AppsTools Paid BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced A1–C1
WritingReadingVocabulary
Details

You write characters with a finger or stylus and it marks stroke order and shape in real time, scheduling reviews so you actually retain them; it ships with HSK, Integrated Chinese and other textbook lists. Only Chinese and Japanese are supported, which is why it is here rather than in the general tools. Roughly $15/month or $100/year after a 7-day trial, and it is worth it only if handwriting is genuinely one of your goals — many learners reasonably skip production of characters entirely.

Adaptive vocabulary training with unusually well-written word explanations.

About this tool →
ToolsWebsites Freemium IntermediateAdvanced B1–C2
VocabularyReading
Details

An adaptive quiz engine that keeps testing you on words in varied contexts until they stick, backed by dictionary entries written as short essays about how a word is really used rather than terse definitions. Building lists from a book or article you are reading and drilling those words is the strongest way to use it. It is aimed largely at American students preparing for standardised tests, so vocabulary skews academic and away from spoken idiom, and serious use of the learner and classroom features needs a subscription.

Chinese-specific spaced repetition with ready-made HSK and textbook word lists.

About this tool →
ToolsWebsites Paid BeginnerIntermediateAdvanced A1–C1
VocabularyReading
Details

A vocabulary SRS built only for Mandarin: import HSK levels, Integrated Chinese chapters or your own lists, and it schedules reviews with sensible defaults instead of Anki's endless configuration. Good for people who want spaced repetition to just work. It is a paid subscription doing something Anki does free, and like all SRS it teaches recognition, not usage — pair it with reading.

A hundred and eighty short Gujarati vocabulary and phrase videos.

About this tool →
YouTube Free Beginner
VocabularySpeaking
Details

Small channel, steady output, everyday words and sentences. Useful as a second voice and for the drip-feed between study sessions; no curriculum to follow.

Six hundred short vocabulary and phrase videos.

About this tool →
YouTube Free Beginner
VocabularyListening
Details

Small channel, very large back catalogue of bite-sized vocabulary and everyday phrases. No curriculum to follow — use it to fill gaps rather than as a course, and check anything that sounds formal against how people actually speak.

Free conjugation and vocabulary drills that let you pick Brazilian or European Portuguese.

About this tool →
ToolsWebsites Free BeginnerIntermediate A1–B2
GrammarVocabularyListening
Details

A no-account browser drill site: conjugation trainer, listening exercises and vocabulary games, with a setting for which Portuguese you want, including the pronunciation used in the audio. It is a drill tool and nothing more — it will not teach you the grammar, only make you fast at what you have already met. Free, no ads, no sign-up.

Video flashcards of real Germans answering — spaced repetition with actual faces.

About this tool →
AppsTools Freemium BeginnerIntermediate A1–B1
SpeakingListeningVocabularyGrammar
Details

Built with the Easy German team, Seedlang replaces text flashcards with short videos of native speakers, so you drill vocabulary and sentence patterns against real pronunciation and gesture. It also has structured grammar decks and Easy German episode tie-ins. German-only in practice, and the free tier is limited enough that you'll hit the paywall quickly if you use it daily.

Six hundred very short Azerbaijani drills.

About this tool →
YouTube Free Beginner
VocabularyListening
Details

A tiny channel with a large catalogue of word and phrase clips. No structure and almost no audience, included because Azerbaijani has few enough resources that volume of native audio is worth having whatever the subscriber count says.

← Browse all learning methods